The Courier-Journal's Sara Cunningham had a story in the Metro Section on Friday about the house that Iroquois High students are renovating as part of the school's technical education program.
Great pictures -- but not a word about access.
This would be a great chance for a home to be made wheelchair accessible. It could have been a "visitable" home.
But... evidently not.
Or else it wasn't reported.
Another missed opportunity to make Louisville's housing stock more welcoming.
Students learn renovation but not access
Posted on
11/20/2007
Filed in: home access, Locales: South End
What happened with coverage of the "house that love built" ?
You'd have to be living under a Metro-area rock -- with no access to any local media at all -- to miss the fact that ABC's Extreme Makeover: Home Edition just completed a new home for U. of L. freshman Patrick Henry Hughes, who uses a wheelchair and is blind, and who lives with his family in the Buechel area.
The home appears to be totally accessible -- although it's hard to find out much about the access details through the fog of inspiration. Despite the almost non-stop media coverage in the C-J and on the local TV stations -- and all their websites -- the story has been played throughout as inspiration, not cutting-edge design. The phrase "the house that love built" has been the headline of at least two (here and here ) and maybe more stories in the C-J. Of course it's the Extreme Makeover folks promoting this.
But they have a willing co-conspirator in Father Hughes. The "inspiration" slant is something Hughes' father, Patrick John Hughes, seems to have been encouraging if not orchestrating for a long time. A Google search of "Patrick Henry Hughes" brings up many stories about the "selfless dad" who marches with his son in the U. of L. band, pushing his wheelchair. Most of these stories end up being more about the father's selflessness than about a college freshman's interests and lifestyle. Makes you wonder a bit. But that's not the topic of this blog posting. (If you want more on what I've learned over the years about such inspirational treatments, you might want to read this and this.)
In all of the media overkill of the last week, we finally get this:
Patrick Henry Hughes eagerly summed up his favorite feature of the new home:
"It's wonderful the fact that the house is more accessible," he said, smiling. "I can do everything by myself when I want to. It's gonna be great!"
Ah yes: that is the point. Too bad it was so thoroughly buried in the story 'Hometown heroes' honored.
I've yet to find any real coverage of what the actual access consists of. I've still got no real idea of precisely why and how Hughes is going to be able to be independent (despite his dad) in his new digs. Those are the pictures I'd like to see. Another story that didn't get reported, along the lines of actual access, comes via yesterday's press release from the University of Louisville -- about how Hughes
will be able to feel the shape and layout inside and out through a plastic model of the home, thanks to efforts at the Rapid Prototyping Center at UofL’s J.B. Speed School of Engineering.
Didn't see this anywhere in all the mass media hoopla, either.
Perhaps the most troubling thing about the way the story has been covered is that access is presented as something "special" being given out of "love" to Hughes by all the selfless volunteers.
Wouldn't it be better -- and more accurate -- to report that home access should be every person's right -- not just a lucky special recipient who gets a "gift"??
What the media coverage has done for me is a little different, maybe, than what it has done for the thousands who have watched and read and "felt good": All the coverage just makes me think of all the other wheelchair users in the community who could use access in their homes -- and could get it, if attention were paid to the issue, rather than focusing on the "inspiration" of one college-age fellow whose dad is ever-present. If Elite Homes, for example, decided to start incorporating the principles of visitability in all their new homes.
It makes me think about how little home access gets discussed at all in the Metro area. I'll try to blog a bit more on that in the future.
If this new home allows Patrick Hughes to quit having to be carried everywhere, that's a winner in my book.
I do have to wonder why the college guy seems to get lifted everywhere by his dad. Hughes the father, were he of a different mindset, perhaps, could use his son not so much as a public inspiration but as a way to draw attention to the things that should be accessible, but aren't.
Now that would be a real act of love -- with presents for a lot more folks than just one family.
Posted on
11/16/2007
Filed in: home access, inspiration, Locales: Bardstown Rd., visitability
Can't get there from here...
So here we are at Wild Eggs (3985 Dutchmans Lane) - reviewed this weekend in the C-J.
Thing is, the accessible parking is way way back in the back, where you have to try to roll past all these cars and squeeze in the narrow passageway -- ooh, can I squeeze past that bench there? oops! watch the planter! -- oops! can I get around that post? Several of 'em -- see 'em? There's a newspaper box sticking out. We're taking the photo right by the box there.
Here's the thing: This photo we took standing right at the front door. It's flat right there -- it's flat all along there. There's parking right at the front door. You can see the cars.
Sure, they could have put the accessible parking right here at the front door.
But nooooo, it's way back in the back.
Any idea why?
This is a NEW RESTAURANT! Just opened!!!
How can they get by with this ridiculous "path of travel" problem?
Posted on
11/04/2007
Filed in: Locales: St. Matthews, parking problems, photos, restaurants, sidewalks
Hidden Access 2
Awhile back I wrote of a restaurant that evidently offered wheelchair access in the rear -- but had no sign in front indicating this was the case.
Are people in wheelchairs just supposed to know they're supposed to come in the back???
Palermo Viejo (1359 Bardstown Rd.) is another such place.
For a long time I thought they had no wheelchair access. There's the usual step at the front door. I also didn't know they had parking in back. Maybe these are things foodies are just supposed to know.
I know that years ago MetroSweep urged Palermo Viejo to put a sign on their front door indicating wheelchair access via a back entrance.
Still hasn't been done.
What's this about? I really don't understand it. The signs are not all that expensive. And in point of law it's illegal not to have one.
But nobody seems to care -- neither the owners or, I guess, wheelchair users, who either don't complain or don't complain effectively, as the asked-for signs rarely appear.
I'd love to get somebody else's take on this.
When business owners fail to provide access because they say it will cost "too much" to install a ramp or widen a door, I don't like that attitude either, and I fight it -- but I at least understand where it's coming from.
But a sign? C'mon! I just spent a little time on google and found those blue wheelie signs as cheap as $12.50. Getting some glue on letters from the hardware store is maybe even cheaper.
So it's not cost. What is it?
Posted on
11/02/2007
Filed in: hidden access, rear-entrance access, restaurants
Too-common problems: towelbar height
The image is of a restaurant restroom. Which restaurant? Doesn't matter. The picture is so typical it could represent dozens of restaurant restrooms in Louisville; thousands nationwide.
It's clear the folks here were thinking of access -- or at least the contractors putting the restroom in were thinking of it. The state building code's access requirements have things spelled out for restroom access.
Yup. Sure do.
"Reach ranges" are spelled out in the code. Nothing -- like towel dispensers, for example -- is supposed to be higher than 48 inches from the floor.
Somebody wasn't using a tape measure when they installed this towel dispenser.
But this restroom is far from unique. In fact, too-high towel dispensers are common in "accessible" restrooms. Why?
I can't figure that one out. Seems like such an easy thing.
Nobody cares? But why would whoever is putting together an accessible restroom WANT to put a towel dispenser so high? Don't they think? Don't they REALIZE that someone who has limited arm mobility would have a hard time reaching this thing?
Don't they think disabled people need to use towels in the restroom?
Don't they think?
Why not?
Posted on
10/21/2007
Filed in: building codes, general, photos, restroom access
Emperor's New Clothes of Restaurant Access
I've been meaning to post a link to the amazing Sept. 12 New York Times article by its Dining critic Frank Bruni about the access -- or lack thereof -- of NYC restaurants. I call it "amazing" because it's the first I've ever seen of a major news article noting the problem of places which insist they ARE "accessible" being anything but.
It's a phenomenon that's all too familiar to diners who use wheelchairs -- but it's rarely talked about: " the ways in which even the most accessible restaurants . . . fail to accommodate disabled diners as well as they do the rest of us."
Bruni's article, When Accessibility Isn’t Hospitality, continued:
I check on restaurants’ wheelchair accessibility every week for my reviews for The Times, but even I didn’t appreciate the obstacles people without full mobility face until I dined with one of them, which is what I did after Jill Abramson, managing editor of The New York Times, was injured in an accident last May. . . .
So while she was progressing from wheelchair to crutches to cane, I went with her to four restaurants that said they were at least partially accessible to see how true that was.
At most of them we encountered hosts and servers who seemed earnestly determined to be as helpful as they could.
But we also encountered unhappy surprises and challenging circumstances. And we learned what disabled diners know too well: eating out is almost never easy. [Emphasis added.]
Bruni's article may have elicited more responses from readers than any other restaurant article he's ever written.
In the emails he received, he wrote in his blog, readers
spoke to how frustrated they feel and how grateful they were to have their reality recognized. Many of the readers who wrote me drew special attention to the discrepancy between the promises of accessibility that restaurants make and the actual experience of visiting those restaurants.
Here are some snips from those emails:
I’m delighted you’ve brought these problems to public awareness. The restaurants that irk me most are the ones that claim to be accessible when I call ahead but in fact have a small flight of steps just to get in the door —steps, no doubt, that the walking person who answered the telephone had never really noticed before.
And
[I]t never fails to amuse me at how easily the word “accessible” is tossed out. As you proved, that term is very much open to interpretation, especially when you aren’t the one disabled.
And
I too have found that in N.Y. most often restaurants say they are accessible and they really are not. Might just be one step but that’s enough to hinder movement.
And
It is amazing how little we think of these things until someone we love is humiliated and distressed at what is supposed to be a pleasant occasion-eating out at a lovely restaurant.(Read the responses here.)
These readers are all pointing out an issue that I'll be returning to in coming days: That "partial" access can end up being truly the same as "no access" -- and perhaps I'll get into a bit about why people complain so infrequently about the problem.
This issue of access is a true sleeper issue -- and it's only going to become bigger as society ages.
While Louisville has a larger proportion of newly built structures housing restaurants, structures that DO MEET access codes, in fact many of our most trendy dining spots, along the Frankfort Ave. and Bardstown Rd. corridors, exhibit the same problems Bruni writes about in Manhattan eateries.
We can do something about the problem here. But will we?
Posted on
10/16/2007
Filed in: general, hidden access, restaurants
What to do about blocked access?
Michelle of consuming louisville has posted a comment about the problems wheelchair users have in the Highlands with cars parking up on the sidewalks on side streets, making the sidewalks impassable.
Cars are a problem -- so are bike racks, bikes, news boxes, big planters, benches bolted to the sidewalk, not to mention those ever-popular outdoor tables in front of coffee shops. Funny how everything can seem to be put onto the sidewalk except ramps. IPL won't permit them to extend onto sidewalks because they block the right of way. (See my blog entry that touches on that.)
Michelle writes,
When cars are preventing access do you know who we should call to address the problem? In the past I've called the local police district but they seem less than pleased with such calls.
I know who I'd call, if I were in a wheelchair: I'd call TV news.
It's sad but amazing how much doesn't change unless a public spotlight shines on it.
I know folks in chairs who have complained repeatedly about folks parking illegally in those accessible parking spots. One guy who use to frequent Jillian's back when it was over there around Baxter used to say he complained so much that the cops came to regard him as a troublemaker -- but the spots never did get cleared.
What's this about?
Many folks don't believe that there's real discrimination against wheelchair users -- it's just that folks don't know what to do, or that providing access costs too much. But too many tales like this one make me think that belief is just a bit simplistic.
Back to the good old organizing tactics:
One person in a wheelchair is a whiner, but two or 3 of them, particularly if they have a crew of supporters, can really make a significant point. That's especially true in Louisville, I think, where lots of wheelchair activism doesn't occur so much -- not like, say, in Denver or Chicago.
Look at the protests Corey Nett's treatment engendered.
I'd love to see similar protests over these impassable sidewalks.
Posted on
10/11/2007
Filed in: IPL, organizing, sidewalks